Document 1: Benjamin of Tudela loves Constantinople and everything about it and it shows in his writing. He discusses the beautiful architecture and trading centers and truly expresses his love for the city, even though heroes mention that the Jewish citizens were treated poorly. Very Credible source.
Document 2: Robert of Clary writes about Constantinople's capture and the Greeks fascination in the city. He addresses this document to the common people.
Document 3: Nicetas Choniates describes via exaggeration the destruction of Constantinople by the Latins and their lack of sympathy and consideration towards the city's valuables and riches.
Document 4: this is a map of Constantinople that shows the society's protection and religion but is not as credible as the other sources because of lack of buildings and other essential aspects.
Document 5: this photo is taken by Bildarchiv Foto Marburg and depicts Saint Sophia, a new form of architecture developed by Constantine.
Document 6: this document is written by George Acropolites and describes Emperor Michael VIII Palaeologus and the Byzantine Empire. Also focuses on Christian influence on Society.
Document 7: Chrysobull describes Venetian ways of life and their success rather than discussing Constantinople.
I believe document 1 is the most credible source because it addresses all important parts about the city from it's beautiful architecture and culture, to its religion and economy. Benjamin of Tudela also describes that even though his love for the city is powerful, there was a downfall beuase the Jews were treated poorly, making the source reliable because it addresses issues of the city as well.
No comments:
Post a Comment